Casement, Double-Hung, or Bay — What Window Type Is Actually Right for Your Home?
June 23, 2026
Article Summary
Double-hung, casement, and bay windows each solve a different problem in your home. Here's how Modern Day Window helps Indianapolis homeowners choose the right style for the right room.
Why does window style matter more than brand or price?
When most Indianapolis homeowners start thinking about replacement windows, they don't realize how many choices they're actually going to face.
The first question usually isn't the brand or the price — it's the style. There are several types of windows, and they're not all the right fit for every room in your house.
Below are the three styles we get the most questions about.
What makes double-hung windows the classic choice?
Raylen Dorrell: Double-hung windows are the classic — the kind most people picture when they think "window."
Both sashes move up and down, which makes them easy to clean and great for ventilation. They work in almost every room and almost every home style.
If you're not sure what you want, double-hung is usually the safe starting point.
When are casement windows the smarter pick?
Casement windows are hinged on the side and crank open outward. When closed, they seal tighter than double-hung — a real advantage in Indiana winters. When open, they deliver maximum airflow.
They're popular in two situations:
Kitchens above counters — where you can't easily reach to slide a window up
Modern-style homes — where a cleaner, more architectural look matters
If energy efficiency and a sleek profile are priorities, casement is worth a serious look.
What do bay windows actually add to a room?
Bay windows are what homeowners add when they want to change the feel of a room.
They project outward from the wall, which does three things at once:
Creates extra natural light
Adds architectural detail and curb appeal
Gives a room perceived square footage without an addition
They're a bigger investment than a standard replacement, but in a living room or primary bedroom, the impact is hard to argue with.
How do you decide which window is right for your home?
The honest answer depends on three things: the room, the wall, and what you're trying to accomplish.
That's a conversation we love having in person. The right window in the wrong room is still the wrong window — and we'd rather walk you through it than guess.
"The right window in the wrong room is still the wrong window."
— Raylen Dorrell, Modern Day Window
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the most popular replacement window style in Indianapolis?
Double-hung windows are the most popular choice for Indianapolis homes because they're easy to clean, offer reliable ventilation, and fit nearly every architectural style.
Are casement windows better for Indiana winters?
Yes. Casement windows seal tighter when closed than double-hung windows, which helps reduce drafts and improve energy efficiency during cold Indiana winters.
Are bay windows worth the extra investment?
For living rooms and primary bedrooms, bay windows often pay back in natural light, curb appeal, and a feeling of added space. They're a higher upfront investment than standard replacements but deliver strong visual impact.
Can I mix window styles in the same house?
Absolutely. Most homeowners use a mix — double-hung in bedrooms, casement over kitchen counters, and a bay window in a featured room — to match each space's function.
How do I choose the right window for each room?
Start with the room's purpose, the wall's layout, and the look you want. A consultation with Modern Day Window helps match the right style to each opening in your home.
Scott Dorrell
About the Author
Scott Dorrell is the Co-Founder of Modern Day Window & Door, known for delivering five-star customer experiences and hands-on product expertise. He’s dedicated to helping homeowners improve comfort, efficiency, and long-term value through high-quality window and door solutions.
