Andersen and Renewal by Andersen are both owned by Andersen Corporation, but they are not the same product line or buying experience. Andersen Windows sells a broad range of window and door products for new construction, replacement, and commercial applications through authorized dealers like Modern Day Window & Door. Renewal by Andersen is a separate retail division that sells a single Fibrex composite replacement window line exclusively through its own franchise network. Same parent company, different products, pricing structures, and installation experiences.
| Feature | Andersen Windows & Doors | Renewal by Andersen |
|---|---|---|
| Parent Company | Andersen Corporation | Andersen Corporation |
| Primary Market | New construction, replacement, commercial | Replacement windows only |
| Product Lines | 100, 200, 400, A-Series, E-Series | Single Fibrex composite line |
| Frame Materials | Wood, Fibrex, Vinyl, Aluminum Clad, Vinyl Clad | Fibrex composite only |
| Where to Buy | Authorized dealers (e.g., Modern Day Window & Door), Home Depot | Renewal by Andersen franchise dealers only |
| Installation | Installed by authorized dealer of your choice | Installed by Renewal franchise rep |
| Price Range (per window, installed) | $400–$1,200+ depending on series and dealer | $800–$1,500+ (premium retail pricing) |
| Warranty | Varies by series; up to 20-year limited warranty | Limited lifetime warranty on Fibrex frame |
| Energy Efficiency | Available across all series; HP SmartSun glass upgrades available | High-performance glass standard |
| Made In | Bayport, Minnesota | Bayport, Minnesota |
| Financing | Available through authorized dealers | Available through Renewal franchise |
Price is one of the most common reasons homeowners research the difference between Andersen and Renewal by Andersen. Here is what you can expect to pay in the Indianapolis area for installed replacement windows.
| Series | Frame Material | Estimated Installed Cost |
|---|---|---|
| Andersen 100 Series | Fibrex composite | $400 – $700 |
| Andersen 200 Series | Vinyl | $450 – $800 |
| Andersen 400 Series | Wood/Aluminum Clad | $600 – $1,100 |
| Andersen A-Series | Wood/Aluminum Clad | $900 – $1,500+ |
| Andersen E-Series | Wood/Aluminum Clad | $1,000 – $2,000+ |
| Product | Frame Material | Estimated Installed Cost |
|---|---|---|
| Renewal by Andersen (all styles) | Fibrex composite | $800 – $1,500+ |
Note: Renewal by Andersen pricing is set by the franchise and is typically non-negotiable. Andersen Windows pricing through an authorized dealer like Modern Day Window & Door can vary based on project scope, window count, and series selected.
Why the price difference? Renewal by Andersen charges more because it operates as a franchise with higher overhead costs for in-home sales and marketing. Andersen Windows sold through an authorized dealer typically cost less than Renewal by Andersen's pricing.
Contact Modern Day Window & Door for a quote on Andersen replacement windows for your Indianapolis-area home.
Warranty coverage differs between the two buying experiences. Here is how they compare.
| Warranty Component | Andersen Windows (via Authorized Dealer) | Renewal by Andersen |
|---|---|---|
| Frame & Sash | Up to 20-year limited warranty (varies by series) | Limited lifetime warranty on Fibrex frame |
| Glass/Insulating Unit | 10–20 years depending on series | 20-year limited warranty |
| Hardware | 10-year limited warranty (400 Series and above) | Lifetime limited warranty |
| Screens | 2-year limited warranty | 2-year limited warranty |
| Installation Labor | Warranty provided by your authorized dealer | Warranty provided by Renewal franchise |
| Transferable to New Owner | Yes, on most series | Yes, with registration |
Renewal by Andersen offers a "limited lifetime warranty" on the Fibrex frame. Andersen offers a 20-year limited warranty on the same component. Both warranties contain exclusions for normal wear, fading, and damage from improper maintenance. The term length and coverage after the stated period ends differ between the two.
Before signing a contract, request the full written warranty document from your contractor. Review the exclusions and coverage limits carefully. This applies to Renewal by Andersen and all other window providers.
Modern Day Window & Door provides warranty documentation on all Andersen window and door installations in the Indianapolis area.
Pros:
Cons:
Pros:
Cons:
The short answer: same parent company, completely different products, pricing, and buying experience. Here is what that actually means when you are shopping for replacement windows.
Andersen Windows & Doors sells multiple product lines: the 100 Series, 200 Series, 400 Series, A-Series, and E-Series. Each is built for different budgets and performance levels. You can buy wood-interior windows, aluminum-clad exteriors, vinyl, or Fibrex composite depending on what your home needs. Andersen products are available for new construction, replacement inserts, and full-frame replacement projects.
Renewal by Andersen sells exactly one product: a Fibrex composite window. There are no series tiers, no wood options, no aluminum-clad options. If Fibrex is not the right material for your home, Renewal by Andersen cannot help you.
Renewal by Andersen windows typically run $800–$1,500+ per window installed. The premium pricing reflects their retail franchise model: you are paying for the brand, the sales process, and the franchise overhead built into every quote.
Andersen windows purchased through an authorized independent dealer like Modern Day Window & Door typically run $400–$1,200+ per window installed, depending on the series you choose. The 100 and 200 Series sit at the lower end; the A-Series and E-Series with premium glass packages sit higher. Because authorized dealers are not locked into a single franchise pricing structure, they can offer competitive quotes and work within your budget across multiple product lines.
On a whole-home project replacing 10–15 windows, that pricing difference can easily reach $5,000–$10,000 or more.
Renewal by Andersen installs windows through its own franchise representatives. You buy from them, and they install. There is no separation between the sales process and the installation crew.
When you buy Andersen through an authorized dealer, you choose your installer. That means you can vet the contractor, check local reviews, compare quotes, and work with someone who has a reputation in your specific community. For Indianapolis-area homeowners, that means working with a local business that stands behind its warranty and service commitments.
Both Andersen Windows and Renewal by Andersen windows are manufactured by Andersen Corporation in Bayport, Minnesota. This is an important point that often gets lost in the comparison: Renewal by Andersen does not make a superior product because of where it is made. Both brands come from the same manufacturing operation.
The Fibrex composite material used in Renewal by Andersen windows is also used in several Andersen product lines available through authorized dealers. The manufacturing origin is identical. What you are paying a premium for with Renewal by Andersen is the retail franchise model and the single-brand sales experience, not a fundamentally different or better-made window.
If you want one product, one material, and a single-company experience and are comfortable paying a premium for that simplicity, Renewal by Andersen delivers a consistent product.
If you want options—different series, different frame materials, competitive pricing, and a local contractor who can match the right window to your home's specific needs—buying Andersen through an authorized independent dealer gives you more flexibility at a lower cost.
For homeowners in Indianapolis, Carmel, Fishers, Noblesville, Fort Wayne, and the surrounding Indiana communities, Modern Day Window & Door is an authorized Andersen dealer. We carry multiple Andersen series, offer free in-home consultations, and provide quotes with no franchise markup. Call us at [PHONE] or schedule your free consultation to compare options for your home.
Renewal by Andersen operates through a national franchise network. When you call them, you are working with a franchise location — not a locally owned business.
Modern Day Window & Door is an authorized Andersen dealer based in Indianapolis, Indiana. We serve homeowners across Marion County, Hamilton County, Hancock County, Boone County, Madison County, Allen County, and Whitley County. We also serve Carmel, Fishers, Noblesville, Westfield, Broad Ripple, Castleton, Beech Grove, Greenfield, Anderson, Lebanon, Fort Wayne, and surrounding communities.
Here is what that means for you:
If you are comparing Andersen vs. Renewal by Andersen and want to see what Andersen windows actually cost through a local authorized dealer, not a franchise, we are ready to show you.
Call us at [PHONE NUMBER] or Request Your Free In-Home Quote →
Is Renewal by Andersen the same as Andersen Windows?
No. Renewal by Andersen and Andersen Windows are both owned by Andersen Corporation, but they are separate divisions with different products, pricing models, and distribution channels. Andersen Windows sells multiple product lines (100, 200, 400, A-Series, E-Series) through authorized dealers and retailers. Renewal by Andersen is a franchise retail division that sells only one product: a Fibrex composite replacement window exclusively through its own franchise network.
What is the difference between Andersen and Renewal by Andersen?
The main differences are product selection, price, and where you buy. Andersen Windows offers wood, vinyl, aluminum clad, and Fibrex frame options across five product series at a range of price points. Renewal by Andersen offers only Fibrex composite frames at a premium retail price set by the franchise. Andersen Windows are available through local authorized dealers who can offer competitive pricing; Renewal by Andersen pricing is non-negotiable through the franchise.
Are Renewal by Andersen windows worth the price?
Renewal by Andersen windows are quality products, but you are paying a significant franchise premium on top of the manufacturing cost. Homeowners who want Andersen Corporation quality without the franchise markup can purchase Andersen 100 Series (also Fibrex composite) or 400 Series windows through an authorized dealer at a lower installed cost. Whether the premium is worth it depends on your budget and how much value you place on the single-source franchise experience.
Where are Renewal by Andersen windows made?
Renewal by Andersen windows are manufactured by Andersen Corporation in Bayport, Minnesota. Both Renewal by Andersen and Andersen Windows products are made at this same location by the parent company.
Can I buy Andersen 100 Series instead of Renewal by Andersen?
Yes. The Andersen 100 Series uses the same Fibrex composite material as Renewal by Andersen windows and is available through authorized dealers like Modern Day Window & Door. The 100 Series is typically available at a lower installed price than Renewal by Andersen while using the same core frame material.
Does Andersen Windows have a better warranty than Renewal by Andersen?
Renewal by Andersen offers a limited lifetime warranty on the Fibrex frame, while Andersen Windows offers up to a 20-year limited warranty depending on the series. Both warranties have exclusions. The Renewal by Andersen lifetime warranty sounds more comprehensive, but the practical coverage difference is minimal for most homeowners. Always request the full written warranty document from any contractor before purchasing.
Can I buy Andersen windows without going through Renewal by Andersen?
Yes. Andersen windows and doors are available through a network of authorized dealers independent of the Renewal by Andersen franchise. Modern Day Window & Door is an authorized Andersen dealer serving Indianapolis, Fort Wayne, and surrounding Indiana communities.
Modern Day Window & Door is an authorized Andersen dealer serving Indianapolis, Carmel, Fishers, Noblesville, Fort Wayne, and communities throughout central and northeast Indiana. We offer the full range of Andersen window and door products, including the 100, 200, 400, A-Series, and E-Series lines, with professional installation, HP SmartSun glass upgrades, and financing options including 0% interest for 24 months.
Schedule a free in-home consultation with our team and get a no-obligation quote on Andersen windows and doors for your home.
Keep up to date with Modern Day Window & Door! Follow us on Facebook.
Interested in learning about our five-star experience and window and door replacement? Schedule a free consultation with us here.
Scott Dorrell is the Co-Founder of Modern Day Window & Door, known for delivering five-star customer experiences and hands-on product expertise. He’s dedicated to helping homeowners improve comfort, efficiency, and long-term value through high-quality window and door solutions.
"*" indicates required fields
12125 E 65th Street
Unit 36021
Indianapolis, IN 46236
2421 Production Drive
Suite 208
Indianapolis, IN 46241
272 Gradle Drive
Carmel, IN 46032
